Wednesday, November 14, 2007

The job

I have a friend who is looking for a new job. He is a truck driver. If he was offered a job that would pay more, was easier, and would somehow bring more prestige, what would you suggest? You would probably at least suggest that he look into it more.

You probably would not chastise him for wanting to earn more doing an easier job. Even as shallow as prestige is, you would not begrudge a truck driver from seeking it. Would you?

These are some of the many differences between ministry as a career and other careers. Most are very critical of ministers who chase money, ease, and prestige.

Those things are me-centered. We want spiritual leaders devoid of pride. Going without is heroic. We want heroes.

There is a difference, a big one. Most people go to work, not because they really want to lend a hand to Corporation X, but because they need income. The earning goal, then is “as much as I can get”. And that’s fine, I’d say, as long as you are doing so honestly.

Pastors have the privilege of working toward what they love and believe in most. The pay goal, then becomes “as much as I need to be able to do this.” You do not want to be paid so much that it hinders the church’s mission, because you care more about the church’s mission than about making money.

In the secular fields a Christian often gets as much as you can in as little time as possible so that she can devote as much time and money toward the Kingdom as possible. Logically, that same Christian, if she were employed by a church, would give as much time for as little money as reality would allow. There are still bills to pay and families to shepherd.

Of course, what works best is when a church generously gives their workers as much as they can afford while the workers keep giving back as much as possible.

I’m guessing Regan will have something very interesting to say about this.

5 comments:

Regan Clem said...

I would get paid more and also have an easier job if I was a minister.

The experience of many others would be the same.

That's all I have to say right now.

Sam said...

A couple of thoughts. I believe that many ministers are underpaid. If you compare the time they put in with someone in another profession, even blue collar workers, they come out on the downside. Add to that the fact that many ministers put in far more hours than what they are paid for in addition to the emotional and spiritual strain the ministry puts on him/her and family.

At the same time, I see that some ministers in mega churches get paid bundles and often they just preach and espouse vision. I know of a minister in a 250 member Presbyterian church in East Tennessee who gets paid over $100,000 a year. For this area, that is bundle.

I am not sure what to think. With all the other crap one has to put up with in ministry, it seems that worrying about finances should not be added to the list. And yet, many (if not most) do, and I am heading towards a profession (teaching) that will probably be in the same boat. Regan and I were talking yesterday and we discussed how much GLCC professors make, and I doubted whether it was much more than $40,000. Not a terrible salary, but in this day and age and in that area not great. Not "free from worry."

Anyway, I am rambling probably because I can't come to a reasoned conclusion.

shannoncaroland said...

Let's say Regan's right (and there are certainly places where he would be). What do you think are the ethics of taking a ministry job in that circumstance? What about switching from one ministry job to another?

Sam said...

It seems that at some point listening to God's calling comes into play. Taking a new ministry position because it offers more money is not a good reason. If it is a place that fits well with you as a minister and the kingdom will be benefited then go for it. I do think there are different standards for minister and secular jobs. As you mentioned in the post, for many their job is just a task to accrue income. But ministry is so much more than that.

Regan Clem said...

It comes across as demeaning and arrogant to say that a minister does his job for a purpose grander than what a worker does his job for. I hope most people do not just work to accrue money. That would be a horrible world. Every job is an act of worship. If it is not, then it should not be done by a follower of Jesus.

Maybe I am just trying to justify my life.

All of the priesthood of believers should do more than just do a job for money. Ministers and everyone else included.